Some stories are complex. Others are just confusing.
There’s a difference between a plot that keeps readers engaged and one that leaves them frustrated—between a story that challenges the mind and one that makes readers give up halfway through because they can’t keep track of what’s happening.
A complicated plot isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Some of the best books weave multiple storylines, unreliable narrators, time jumps, or intricate mysteries. But when complexity turns into chaos—when subplots spiral out of control, when necessary details are unclear, when the story stops making sense—then the reader isn’t intrigued. They’re lost.
So how do you tell if your plot is complex in a good way or just a tangled mess? And if it is too complicated, how do you fix it without gutting the heart of your story?
1. If You Can’t Summarize It, It Might Be Too Complicated
A strong story can usually be distilled into one or two sentences. If you struggle to summarize your plot without explaining half the worldbuilding, naming ten characters, or including footnotes, there’s a good chance it’s too convoluted.
👉 Test it: Try the movie trailer test. Imagine your book is a film. If you had to pitch it in 30 seconds, what would you say?
Compare these two pitches:
- Overly Complicated: In a world where time travelers are hunted by the government and a secret underground rebellion is led by an exiled scientist who may or may not have caused the war between the timelines, a journalist trying to expose a conspiracy discovers she was erased from history and must find a missing artifact that— (Wait… what?)
- Clear but Still Complex: A journalist discovers she was erased from history and must uncover the truth before the people hunting her erase her for good.
The second version keeps the intrigue but avoids overloading the listener with unnecessary layers.
👉 Fix it:
- Write your one-sentence pitch. If you can’t, simplify.
- Identify which elements of your plot are essential—and which are just making it harder to follow.
2. If Readers Keep Getting Confused, That’s a Red Flag
Have you ever gotten feedback like:
- “Wait, who is this character again?”
- “I don’t understand what just happened.”
- “I had to reread that section three times.”
This means your story isn’t delivering necessary information clearly enough.
👉 Test it: Ask a beta reader to explain the plot back to you after reading a few chapters. If they misinterpret major events or struggle to explain character motivations, your story might be too dense or unclear.
👉 Fix it:
- Make sure critical information is surfaced at the right time—don’t bury key details in one-off dialogue lines or obscure descriptions.
- Introduce characters and concepts gradually, rather than all at once.
- Ensure each major event has a clear cause-and-effect—if a reader asks why something happened and there’s no clear answer, you need to clarify.
3. Too Many Subplots Might Be Distracting From the Core Story
Subplots can enrich a book, adding layers of character development and intrigue. But if a story has too many competing narratives, it starts feeling disjointed instead of deep.
Signs your subplots are overcomplicating the story:
- The main plot stalls while subplots take over.
- Certain subplots never connect back to the core story.
- Some characters have entire arcs that don’t actually affect the protagonist.
👉 Fix it:
- Map out your story and identify which subplots actually change the main character’s journey. If a subplot can be removed without affecting the outcome, consider cutting or condensing it.
- Ask: Does this subplot add tension, stakes, or emotional depth? If it doesn’t, it might just be clutter.
4. If You Have to Keep Explaining the World, It’s Too Dense
Complex worldbuilding is great—until it overwhelms the story. If you find yourself stopping the plot every few pages to explain how the magic system works, the political structure, the history of the kingdom, your worldbuilding might be slowing everything down.
👉 Test it: Look at your first few chapters. How much time is spent on plot and character versus on explanations of the world?
👉 Fix it:
- Integrate worldbuilding naturally—let readers discover details through action, not through long exposition.
- Give only what’s necessary when it’s necessary. You don’t have to explain every rule of the magic system in Chapter One.
Think of worldbuilding like iceberg storytelling—only show what’s relevant, and let the depth reveal itself naturally.
5. Complicated Twists Only Work If They Feel Earned
A great twist should feel inevitable in hindsight—not like it came out of nowhere.
If your plot twist requires pages of explanation to make sense, it might be too convoluted.
👉 Test it:
- Can a reader look back and see the clues leading up to the twist?
- If you had to explain the twist in a single paragraph, would it make sense?
👉 Fix it:
- Plant subtle foreshadowing—hints that don’t give the twist away but make it feel right when revealed.
- If the twist overcomplicates the entire story, consider whether it actually adds emotional or thematic depth, or if it’s just trying to be clever.
Final Thoughts: The Fine Line Between Complex and Confusing
A strong plot doesn’t have to be simple—but it does have to be clear. If readers can’t follow what’s happening, if they feel lost instead of intrigued, your story might be too complicated for its own good.
If you’re worried about this, ask yourself:
✅ Can I summarize my plot in one sentence?
✅ Can a reader explain my story without getting confused?
✅ Do my subplots add to the core narrative, or just clutter it?
✅ Does my worldbuilding enhance the story, or slow it down?
If the answer to any of these is no, your book might need some streamlining. Because complexity isn’t about how much you can fit into a story.
It’s about how well it all works together.
Leave a Reply