Some books don’t end.
Not in the way you expect, anyway. They leave things open, unresolved, deliberately incomplete. A mystery with no solution. A final page that feels like it’s missing the last paragraph. A story that doesn’t close the door, but leaves it slightly ajar, as if something is still waiting on the other side.
Readers often describe these books as frustrating, unsettling—sometimes even haunting. But is that a flaw? Or is there something deliberate at play?
This is The Hollow Book Phenomenon—the idea that some stories are designed to feel unfinished, that their power comes not from giving the reader closure, but from leaving them searching for answers that were never meant to be found.
Why Some Books Feel Incomplete (And Why It Works Anyway)
1. The Ending Is a Question, Not an Answer
Traditional storytelling teaches us that endings should be satisfying—that conflicts should be resolved, that characters should complete their arcs, that the reader should walk away feeling like the journey had a purpose.
But some stories operate differently. Instead of providing resolution, they leave the reader with something unresolved, something that lingers long after the last page is turned.
- The Turn of the Screw by Henry James never confirms whether the ghosts are real or just a hallucination.
- No Country for Old Men by Cormac McCarthy ends mid-thought, abruptly severing the story before a “proper” conclusion.
- The Trial by Franz Kafka ends without explanation—because in a world ruled by senseless bureaucracy, explanation itself is impossible.
These books aren’t unfinished. They’re hollow by design. The absence of resolution is part of the point.
2. Some Books Invite the Reader to Fill in the Gaps
A story that gives the reader everything leaves them satisfied. A story that makes them search for answers lingers in their mind.
Some books refuse to explain themselves because they want the reader to participate—to draw their own conclusions, to argue over interpretations, to mentally complete the book in their own way.
- House of Leaves by Mark Z. Danielewski refuses to let the reader fully understand what’s real and what isn’t. The novel itself is an unsolvable puzzle, making the reader part of the mystery.
- Inception (yes, the movie, but the principle applies) ends with the spinning top, never confirming whether the protagonist is dreaming or awake—because that choice belongs to the audience.
- Ambiguous endings in literary fiction (think Hemingway, Murakami, Paul Auster) often suggest that resolution isn’t the point—the search for meaning is.
In a way, these books function like unfinished paintings. They provide just enough detail to suggest the full picture, but leave gaps where the reader’s own imagination has to do the work.
3. The Story Isn’t Just About the Plot—It’s About the Experience
Some books aren’t meant to tell a complete story in the traditional sense. They exist to evoke a feeling, to create an atmosphere, to unsettle the reader rather than satisfy them.
Think about the difference between a riddle with an answer and a mystery that deepens the more you think about it.
- David Lynch’s Mulholland Drive doesn’t provide a clear narrative because it isn’t meant to be solved—it’s meant to be felt.
- Kazuo Ishiguro’s The Unconsoled strings the reader through an endless dreamscape, where nothing resolves in a conventional way.
- The works of Haruki Murakami often introduce supernatural elements or unsolvable mysteries that are never explained—because the point isn’t understanding, it’s experiencing the strangeness of the world.
In these cases, the hollowness isn’t a flaw. It’s the whole reason the story works.
When an Open-Ended Story Fails (And When It Works)
Not every ambiguous or incomplete story is deep or meaningful—sometimes, a story just feels unfinished because the writer didn’t know how to end it.
So what’s the difference?
A bad unresolved story feels like:
- A book that builds to something, then stops abruptly with no thematic reason.
- A mystery that isn’t really a mystery—just an underdeveloped plot hole.
- A story that accidentally leaves things vague because the writer didn’t know how to resolve them.
A good unresolved story feels like:
- A book that leaves the reader thinking, rather than just confused.
- An ending that doesn’t provide all the answers, but makes perfect sense emotionally.
- A deliberate choice, not an accident.
How Writers Can Use the Hollow Effect in Their Own Work
If you want to create a book that lingers in the reader’s mind, rather than one that neatly ties everything up, here’s how to do it without making it feel like an accident.
1. Make Sure the Ending Feels Like an Ending—Even If It Doesn’t “Resolve” Everything
The best unresolved endings don’t just stop—they land somewhere meaningful. A scene, a moment, an image that leaves the reader with a feeling of completion, even if the plot isn’t fully wrapped up.
- The Sopranos’ cut-to-black ending worked because it wasn’t just missing information—it was an intentional final statement on uncertainty and fate.
- Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale ends with an ambiguous historical note, forcing the reader to decide how much of Offred’s story was erased.
It’s not about leaving the reader hanging. It’s about leaving them with something to think about.
2. Use Absence as a Narrative Tool
Sometimes, what isn’t said carries more weight than what is. If a story leaves a key piece missing, the reader will naturally obsess over it, trying to complete the puzzle.
- Shirley Jackson’s We Have Always Lived in the Castle never directly explains its protagonist’s crimes, making her all the more unsettling.
- Cormac McCarthy’s The Road refuses to tell us what destroyed the world, because the story is about surviving, not explaining.
By withholding just the right amount of information, you make the reader engage more deeply.
3. Let the Reader Do the Final Work
If you want a book to feel bigger than its pages, let the reader bring themselves into it.
- Instead of stating the theme outright, let them interpret it.
- Instead of tying up every character’s fate, leave space for possibility.
- Instead of making sure the reader understands everything, make sure they feel something real.
The stories that stay with us the longest are often the ones that don’t give us closure—but make us keep searching for it, even after the last page is turned.
Final Thoughts: Some Books Are Designed to Echo
The best stories don’t always resolve. Some of them linger. Some of them refuse to close completely.
Not because they were left unfinished, but because they were designed to leave a space—a hollow in the narrative that the reader has to fill in themselves.
Because the best books aren’t just read.
They’re lived with. And the ones that leave us unsettled? The ones that don’t fully resolve?
They’re the ones that never really leave us at all.
Leave a Reply