Some sentences move like poetry—clean, sharp, deliberate. Others wander, stretching across the page, dragging the reader through a labyrinth of commas and clauses, looping back on themselves before finally—mercifully—stumbling to a halt.
You’ve read these sentences. You’ve probably written them. They start out fine, then suddenly, you’re adding another phrase, then a parenthetical aside (because you just have to clarify something), and before you know it, the sentence has spiraled into a tangled mess.
This is The Sentence That Never Ends Theory—the idea that some writers instinctively overcomplicate their sentences, not because they don’t know how to write concisely, but because they’re chasing something bigger than clarity.
But when do long sentences work? And when do they destroy your writing?
Why Some Writers Gravitate Toward Long Sentences
1. The “More Words = More Meaning” Trap
Some writers believe that more words = more depth. They’re not necessarily wrong—longer sentences can create rhythm, tension, or atmosphere.
But sometimes, a long sentence is just… a long sentence.
If a sentence could be cut in half without losing impact, it might not be as profound as you think.
👉 How to tell if a sentence is too long:
- Does it have more than two commas, semicolons, or dashes?
- Could you split it into two sentences without losing anything important?
- Do you run out of breath reading it aloud?
If the answer is yes, the sentence might be bloated.
2. The Fear of Sounding “Too Simple”
Some writers stretch their sentences because they don’t trust simplicity. A short sentence feels too easy, too basic, as if a longer one would somehow prove they’re better writers.
But great writing isn’t about complexity—it’s about precision.
Compare these two versions of the same thought:
✖ Overwritten: It was in the quiet moments between conversations, in the spaces where words failed to reach, that she truly felt the weight of what had been left unspoken, pressing against her like an invisible force, lingering in the air long after the conversation had ended.
✔ Stronger: She felt it most in the silence—the weight of what wasn’t said.
Same meaning. One is just cleaner.
3. The “Trying to Sound Like a Classic Author” Problem
Some writers (especially those who love classic literature) think long = literary. They model their writing after Faulkner, Woolf, or Joyce, hoping to capture that same sense of depth and complexity.
But those writers weren’t using long sentences just to sound smart. They used them to:
- Mimic train-of-thought thinking (Faulkner).
- Create a hypnotic, immersive rhythm (Woolf).
- Trap the reader in a character’s mind without escape (Joyce).
👉 Lesson: If you’re writing long sentences just because classic authors did, stop. Only do it if it serves the story.
When Long Sentences Work (And When They Kill Your Writing)
✅ When Long Sentences Help:
✔ For tension-building: A long, unbroken sentence can mimic anxiety, urgency, or spiraling thoughts.
✔ For lyrical, poetic moments: When the sound of a sentence matters as much as its meaning.
✔ For stream-of-consciousness writing: If a character’s mind is racing, a longer sentence can capture that momentum.
❌ When Long Sentences Hurt:
✖ When they confuse the reader. If the sentence forces someone to reread it, it’s failing.
✖ When they slow the pacing. A thriller shouldn’t have page-long sentences.
✖ When they’re stuffed with filler. If the same idea could be said in fewer words, do it.
How to Fix Long, Unruly Sentences
1. Break It Into Two Sentences
Most long sentences don’t need to be long. They just need a well-placed period.
✖ The sky, thick with storm clouds, pressed low over the city, a dull gray blanket that turned even the most vibrant streets into something colorless, drained, lifeless, as if the weather itself had sucked the energy from the air.
✔ Fixed: The sky pressed low over the city, thick with storm clouds. Even the most vibrant streets looked dull, drained of color, like the weather had stolen their energy.
Same feeling. Just cleaner.
2. Read It Out Loud
If you run out of breath before finishing a sentence, it’s too long.
Your brain processes spoken words differently than written ones—if a sentence feels unnatural when spoken, it might need to be restructured.
3. Cut Every Unnecessary Word
✖ She had a feeling, one she couldn’t quite name, that something wasn’t right.
✔ Fixed: She felt it—something was wrong.
✖ The darkness seemed to stretch on forever, as if the night itself had no end in sight.
✔ Fixed: The darkness stretched endlessly, swallowing everything.
Rule: If a word isn’t adding new meaning, it’s dead weight.
Final Thoughts: Find the Balance
Not every sentence should be short. Not every sentence should be long. Great writing is about contrast.
Mix short, punchy sentences with longer, flowing ones. If everything is long, the reader gets lost. If everything is short, the writing feels choppy.
So next time you find yourself writing a never-ending sentence, stop. Ask yourself:
📌 Is this sentence long because it needs to be? Or just because I’m afraid to cut it?
If it’s the second one?
Trim it down. Let it breathe.
Because sometimes, the strongest sentence is the one that knows when to stop.
Leave a Reply